Local Editorials

Our view: Cheering that new Illinois budget? Not so fast

Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner displays the signed Illinois state budget for fiscal 2019 Monday in Chicago. It is the first full-year spending plan he's enacted since taking office in 2015. The Republican, who's seeking re-election in November, was joined at Monday's bill signing by legislators from both parties who hailed the budget as a bipartisan compromise.
Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner displays the signed Illinois state budget for fiscal 2019 Monday in Chicago. It is the first full-year spending plan he's enacted since taking office in 2015. The Republican, who's seeking re-election in November, was joined at Monday's bill signing by legislators from both parties who hailed the budget as a bipartisan compromise.

We in Illinois have a way of lowering expectations when it comes to our state government. For example, we are currently on our second consecutive governor who has not been convicted of a federal crime. Woohoo! And just last week lawmakers passed a full-year operating budget during the regular legislative session. Fantastic!

Not so fast.

Although Gov. Bruce Rauner signed the budget Monday, flanked by Democrats and Republicans, and although we are optimistic about his assertion the deal moves the state forward, it is fair to turn attention to actual analysis of the budget. Something being the product of negotiations comparatively free of contention doesn’t mean it actually improves things in our fiscally forlorn state.

On Tuesday, S&P Global Ratings released an analysis of the $38.5 billion spending plan, calling it “more of the same,” which is not exactly encouraging given we’ve already got the worst credit rating among all 50 states — one level above junk status, according to The Associated Press.

Sure, the timeliness is a good sign. And given the alternative of many more months of uncertainty, stopgap spending bills and intense partisan bickering, it’s nice to be in this lane for a bit. But S&P doesn’t have any emotions in the game, and so it’s useful for taxpayers to give heed to an indication the budget simply continues past practices of banking on revenue and savings that may not materialize.

One example is a reliance on $270 million from the sale of the James R. Thompson Center, a state office building in Chicago lawmakers have discussed selling for years. The budget also assumes savings from a pension buyout the agency describes as “uncertain” — a polite way of saying there’s not a real likelihood of recouping the projected $400 million —and doesn’t pay down billions in bills or set aside money for a reserve fund.

So as usual, we taxpayers find ourselves wondering when another shoe will drop. Sure, the budget doesn’t increase any tax rates — the last bump is generating more than expected, which is nice or naughty, depending on if you ask a government worker or a layperson — but if these projected savings and profits don’t materialize in full, then we’re still in the position of operating government we can’t afford.

That situation will, eventually, bring all the relevant players back to the same bargaining table. It might be after the November election, or even a few years down the road and so the faces could be different, but the problems will be real and familiar. Nothing will truly get better in Illinois fiscally until the money out equals the money coming in and lawmakers have firm control on both numbers.

Ideally we’d spend less than we earn and then actually save a little to manage future uncertainties. But again, this is Illinois, where we have lowered our expectations to much that even the good news is rarely more than a dimly silver lining.

Loading more

Digital Access

Digital Access
Access nwherald.com from all your digital devices and receive breaking news and updates from around the area.

Home Delivery

Home Delivery
Local news, prep sports, Chicago sports, local and regional entertainment, business, home and lifestyle, food, classified and more! News you use every day! Daily, weekend and Sunday packages.

Text Alerts

Text Alerts
Stay connected to us wherever you are! Get breaking news updates along with other area information sent to you as a text message to your wireless device.

Email Newsletters

Email Newsletters
We'll deliver news & updates to your inbox. Plan your weekend and catch up on the news with our newsletters.